Workers’ Compensation

Ca. Workers' Comp. Quarterly Vol. 35, No. 1, 2022

The See’s Candies Decision: Employers May Be Liable for Third-Party Covid Damages Traced Back to Their Employees

THOMAS A. RICHARD, ESQ.

OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA

The Covid-19 pandemic has been very challenging and risky for California employers. They face the difficulties of maintaining a safe work environment while complying with ever-shifting regulatory requirements, as well as a rise in Covid-related workers’ compensation claims, including some presumed compensable claims. Now employers face yet another challenge: the risk of civil liability when third parties, particularly employees’ household members, are exposed to ill employees. A new California Court of Appeal decision has opened the door to "take-home liability" for workplace-acquired Covid illnesses and challenged the "exclusive remedy" defense, which has long shielded employers from separate civil court damages that originate from industrial injuries.

Nationally, the exclusive remedy rule generally bars the filing of liability lawsuits against employers by injured employees and their family members. Instead, workers’ compensation benefits are understood to be the exclusive remedy available to an employee and to their family members who claim damages that derive from that on-the-job injury. However, California’s Second District Court of Appeal rejected the exclusive remedy defense in a Covid wrongful death case, Matilde Ek et al. v. See’s Candies Inc., et al. (2021) 87 Cal.Comp.Cases 21. Instead, employee Matilde Ek was allowed to sue her employer for the alleged Covid-related death of her husband. The case could have significant ramifications in California, if not nationally.

Join CLA to access this page

Join Now

Forgot Password

Enter the email associated with you account. You will then receive a link in your inbox to reset your password.

Personal Information

Select Section(s)

CLA Membership is $99 and includes one section. Additional sections are $99 each.

Payment