Ca. Tax Lawyer 2017, VOLUME 26, NUMBER 1
- 2016 Annual Meeting of the California Tax Bar & California Tax Policy Conference Report
- Bar Business
- Charles Moll Honored With the 2016 Benjamin F. Miller Award
- Constructive Receipt Tax Rules Every Lawyer Should Know
- Gap Between Tax and Sanctions Law Blocks Lifesaving Aid
- Honorable Marshall Whitley (Ret.) Honored With the 2016 Joanne M. Garvey Award
- Legislative Proposal for Infusing Guaranteed Fairness in Tax Administration by Allowing Partial Prepayment Judicial Review of Ftb-proposed Personal Income and Franchise Tax Deficiencies
- Message from the Chair
- Nathan Hochman Honored With the 2016 V. Judson Klein Award
- Proposal to Permit Liability Netting for Partnerships Subject to Involuntary Conversion
- Taxation Section 2016-2017 Leadership Directory
- The 2016 Benjamin F. Miller Award Acceptance Speech
- The 2016 Joanne M. Garvey Award Acceptance Speech
- Visiting the Committees
- Separation of the Sections from the State Bar
Separation of the Sections from the State Bar
By Betty J. Williams
As this edition was about to go to print, I asked the Editor in Chief for additional space to share an important update concerning the inevitable separation of the sections from the State Bar. I have been involved with the Council of Sections (comprised of the Chair and sometimes past-Chair of each of the 16 practice group Sections of the State Bar) and have participated in countless conference calls and in-person meetings concerning the future of the Sections. These meetings have included members of the State Bar’s executive staff, Sections’ support staff, the Board of Trustees, and the press.
The Taxation Section voted early on to join the vote of the Business Law Section to separate from the bar. It became clear to the Taxation Section Executive Committee that the State Bar’s Executive Director, Elizabeth Parker, and Chief Operating Officer, Leah Wilson, were taking actions consistent with their intent to separate the Sections from the State Bar without our input. In addition to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act compliance minutia and headache affecting our leadership of the various volunteer projects offered by the Taxation Section, we were suddenly prohibited from completing our contracts entered into with various vendors for our 2016 Annual Meeting of the California Tax Bar and California Tax Policy Conference, due to the "optics" of using our funds for networking events that included entertainment such as Las Vegas style gaming, and a photo fun booth. Understand that our bylaws allow the Executive Committee to approve such expenditures if certain criteria are met, including that we have paid any liabilities to the State Bar for its administrative services. Also know that the funds used for these activities did not come from our member’s dues, but rather from outside sponsors who agreed to pay for the events so that all conference attendees could enjoy the networking time together.
We went to the Board of Trustees, to whom Parker and Wilson must answer, for assistance with what we felt were well-reasoned and logical requests, citing both contracts law and our bylaws. Remarkably, the Board of Trustees was not willing to direct Parker to proceed as we requested. One Board Member stated he had concerns about how it "would look" if the Board of Trustees directed Parker on her actions. As a result, we received no assistance and had to achieve our goal through other channels at the cost to our Section members and threatening future sponsorship relationships.